Holmium Advanced Laser Systems – a Better Choice for Q-switched Operations than Thulium Fiber Laser

Holmium Advanced Laser Systems

Performance of Rare-Earth Ions

Trivalent rare earth ions Tm3+ and Ho3+ show extraordinary results for the high power continuous wave and pulsed laser operation in 2 µ wavelength range. Thulium fiber laser is, in general, better for CW operations, when holmium laser is preferred for pulsed and q-switched lasers operations because of its high gain. However, holmium can be excited around 1.9 µ for an efficient operation at 2.1 µ, or it needs to exploit some energy transfer from thulium or ytterbium.

Evolution of Holmium Laser Products

Before recently, holmium laser products were created as co-doped systems, because there weren’t any laser diodes that could provide wavelength ranges for pumping Ho3+ ions. Mostly, thulium co-doping was used, because its ions cross relaxation process properties. Currently, the most potential option to reach the highest output powers is in-band pumping of Ho:YAG crystals. It is possible in 1.9 µ wavelength range.

Industrial and LIDAR Applications

There are a lot of different applications that need short laser pulses with high pulse energies or high CW powers at the 2.1 µ wavelength, which makes holmium lasers in high demand on the market. Mainly, holmium advanced laser systems are created using thulium crystals or fiber lasers for pumping. Moreover, 2.1 µ wavelength is eye safe, because the emission doesn’t reach the retina, which makes it not dangerous for eyes. This wavelength range makes holmium laser in demand for commercial use, especially for LIDAR systems, which operate similarly to radars. 2 µ wavelength allows one to absorb certain atmospheric gasses (e.g. H2O, CO2, N2O) to detect and to analyse them. One of the key advantages of this laser for LIDAR technology is the capability to detect specific lighter atmospheric gasses and molecules. It has a greater potential than thulium fiber laser in chemical and petroleum industries due to safety and quality control as well as in medicine and environmental research.

Medical Applications

Moreover, holmium laser is very promising in terms of medical applications. High water absorption allows performing extra precise surgeries; 2.1 µ emission coagulation effects minimize bleeding. Ho:YAG penetrates into a soft tissue at the depth of 300 µ. However, thulium fiber laser has its own advantages in performing surgical procedures. Holmium laser systems have a lot of potential and, definitely, require further developments and research. They can be applied in a lot of different industries for various purposes, including spectroscopy, sensing and surgery.

Thulium Fiber Laser for LIDAR and Gas Sensing Systems

Thulium Fiber Laser

Introduction to Thulium Fiber Lasers

Ultra-short pulsed femto- and picosecond lasers are in high demand today. Thulium-doped lasers, definitely, stand out because of their capability to generate emissions in a wide range. Thulium Fiber Laser has unique qualities which make it perfect for a lot of different applications, namely, medicine, spectroscopy, laser ranging and micromachining of transparent materials, in particular, semiconductors and laser for LIDAR. Presently, they are the most effective sources of a single-mode emission with the wavelength in 2 µ range.

Medical and Biological Applications

Thulium Fiber Laser water absorption properties are outstanding. The main constituent of any biological tissues is water, which is why strong water absorption quality of thulium laser allows significant heating of small areas. In other words, cutting biological tissues becomes extra precise. All of the above make Thulium Fiber Laser irreplaceable when it comes to performing surgical procedures.

Advantages for Free-Space and Sensing Applications

Thulium lasers compared to traditional optimal cost-efficient laser systems that operate at shorter wavelengths have undeniable advantages when using for free space applications. It gives them a high commercial value, especially as laser for LIDAR and gas sensing systems, optical communication applications and pumping lasers for the mid infra-red spectrum.

Host Materials and Laser Types

Thulium doped lasers are released either in fiber or crystal host materials. Depending on the host material the wavelength range spreads from 1840 nm to 2100 nm. Thulium fiber can either be a q-switched laser or continuous wave laser, and both develop significantly a high average power. On the other hand, thulium doped crystals have a broad emission spectrum, which allows a large wavelength tuning range. Thulium doped crystals are of really good quality with a few imperfections and defects. YAG and YFL crystals reveal the best quality nowadays; however, they are not the best choices because of their thermal conductivity and emission cross section. There is definitely a room for improvement, and further research has to be done to enhance their performance.
Despite the fact that there are so many different applications in a lot of industries only few laser technology providers can deliver this type of laser at the moment. Currently, Optromix is developing its own thulium laser and will release it shortly for commercial use (e.g. laser for LIDAR).

Powerful laser equipment: Nd:YLF Laser or Nd:YAG Laser

NdYLF Laser

Introduction to Nd:YLF Laser

Nd:YLF laser active elements are made of yttrium lithium fluoride (YLiF4) crystal. YLF stands for Yttrium Lithium Fluoride. Usually neodymium-doped YLF crystal is used for YLF laser equipment; however, it can also be doped with rare earth elements, such as ytterbium (Yb), erbium (Er), thulium (Tm), holmium (Ho) or praseodymium (Pr).

Crystal Composition and Properties

Yttrium ions in YLF crystal may be substituted with laser-active rare earth ions, because of its similar size, without distorting the structure of crystal lattice. In neodymium-doped YLF crystal its (Nd3+) concentration is usually up to 1% of its total weight.

Birefringence and Polarization

YLF crystal has a natural strong birefringence, which removes thermal polarization losses. Besides the emission wavelength and the gain of the Nd:YLF crystal waves are polarization-dependent, there is a stronger wave of 1047 nm and a weaker one of 1047 nm. It makes Nd:YLF crystal better for a less powerful laser equipment that require extra precision.

Matching Wavelengths for Amplifiers

1053 nm wavelength matches the maximum for loop gain of phosphate laser glass, that contains neodymium ions, that is why Nd:YLF lasers are often used as a master oscillator and preamplifier for the subsequent stages of the neodymium phosphate glass amplifier.
Diode-pumping and lamp-pumping is possible for Nd:YLF laser. It has lower thermal conductivity in comparison with Nd:YAG laser, but its thermal distortions are weaker, which leads to a better beam quality and worse fracture resistance, hence it limits the output power in the laser equipment.

Nd:YAG is an Optimal Cost-Efficient Laser for Scientific Laser Systems

Nd:YAG laser

Introduction to Nd:YAG Lasers

YAG stands for yttrium aluminum garnet, which is a synthetic crystal. Nd:YAG is an artificial cubic garnet crystal. YAG crystals were created shortly after ruby laser discovery. They have high gain and other unique properties which make them universal for a lot of different applications. YAG crystals increase the stability of the source, its efficiency and lifespan, reduce size and power consumption.

Limitations and Operating Properties

There are certain limitations connected with the high gain and the safety of the operating fluence. Mode-lock property creates pulses of very different widths – nanosecond to picoseconds, which enables it to make wide-ranging peak power for various applications.

Technical Characteristics of Nd:YAG Lasers

YAG laser is a solid state diode pumped laser, its beam is in mid infra-red range and its wavelength is 1064 nm. Nd:YAG is an outstanding solution for scientific laser systems because it can reach extremely high powers in a pulsed mode, which is used in the oscillators to produce series of very short pulses to perform research with femtosecond time resolution.
Nd:YAG laser may be used with a frequency doubler, in this case its wavelength is 532 nm and its output power is lower.

Applications of Nd:YAG Lasers

In terms of applications, yag laser systems are very versatile. It has been widely used in the military, for example, for rangefinding or for target designation.
On the other hand, as mentioned before its pulse width and high power, it is extremely useful for scientific purposes, or as a pumping source for other lasers.
Medicine is another field where Nd:YAG is frequently used, namely dermatology and ophthalmology. Commercial purposes include applications such as ablation, spectroscopy, marking, nondestructive testing and others. Moreover, it is an optimal cost-efficient laser.
Key feature of the YAG lasers is its resilience to different environmental conditions; hence it suits perfectly well for remote sensing, bathymetry, gated imaging illumination, atmospheric and ocean studies, etc.
Other lasers or nonphotonic techniques may be used for most of the applications mentioned above, for example, diode or CO2 lasers. Nd:YAG allows to perform a broad range of applications, because of its one-of-a-kind properties, and also, not many lasers have an ability to function efficiently with diode pumping and to switch between pulsed or CW mode.